Big Secret

[Grudunza]

Ryuk Wrote:

Grudunza Wrote:

SPARTAN VI Wrote:a couple people in my group are reluctant to try custom scenarios.

I feel reluctant to spend the time to try them out when I don't know how well they really work.

Is this how most people feel about home-brewed senarios?

Keep in mind what I added... that when I play the game there's usually somebody new involved. I just don't like the idea of playing something that is untested when new players are involved. If I was playing this regularly with the same tight knit group, I would definitely want to try some of the fan scenarios. Actually, if there are fan scenarios that have corroborating playtests, where several different people have said "yeah, it works really well", then I'd probably be willing to throw it into any game if it sounded cool enough. Problem is that most of the custom scenarios I've read about have several replies of people saying "That sounds great! I'll have to try it!" but then there are no replies of people having actually tried it to know whether it really worked well or not.

Any recommendations for good custom scenarios that you've played?